| King Ecgbert School | Outstanding | Academy | 11 to 18 |
| Totley Brook Road, Sheffield, S17 3QU |
| Mercia School | Outstanding | Academy | 11 to 18 |
| Carter Knowle Road, Sheffield, S7 2DY |
| Phoenix School of Therapeutic Education | Outstanding | Independent (special) | 11 to 17 |
| 83 East Bank Road, Sheffield, S2 3PX |
| Tapton School | Outstanding | Academy | 11 to 18 |
| Darwin Lane, Sheffield, S10 5RG |
| All Saints’ Catholic High School | Good | Academy | 11 to 18 |
| Granville Road, Sheffield, S2 2RJ |
| Bents Green School | Good | Special | 11 to 19 |
| Ringinglow Road, Sheffield, S11 7TB |
| Bethany School | Good | Independent | 4 to 16 |
| Finlay Street, Sheffield, S3 7PS |
| Brantwood Specialist School | Good | Independent (special) | 7 to 19 |
| 1 Kenwood Bank, Nether Edge, Sheffield, S7 1NU |
| Chapeltown Academy | Good | Academy | 16 to 19 |
| Hydra Business Park, Nether Lane, Sheffield, S35 9ZX |
| Firth Park Academy | Good | Academy | 11 to 16 |
| Fircroft Avenue, Sheffield, S5 0SD |
| Forge Valley School | Good | Academy | 11 to 16 |
| Wood Lane, Sheffield, S6 5HG |
